Simple Life Amish Store
Amish Country Surprise Box (Not Christmas themed). Small size
Amish Country Surprise Box (Not Christmas themed). Small size
Couldn't load pickup availability
🕯️ The Amish Mystery Box – A Simple Life Surprise
Step into the heart of Amish Country with our Amish Mystery Box, filled with hand-selected treasures from small family workshops, kitchens, and craft tables in New Wilmington, Pennsylvania.
Every box is different — a surprise mix of Amish-made goods that might include:
- Handcrafted wooden toys or home décor
- Goat milk soaps or tallow balm
- Homemade jams, jellies, or candies
- Crocheted or hand-stitched items
- Little keepsakes from Amish country
- Special sweet treats
Each box tells a story of simple living, faith, and craftsmanship. Whether it’s a gift for yourself or someone you love, the Amish Mystery Box brings a piece of peace, tradition, and small-town beauty right to your doorstep.
✨ Available in Small or Large Box Sizes
No two boxes are alike — just like the hands that made what’s inside.
Share
I absolutely loved my box. I have an allergy to strawberries, raspberries and blackberries and i was able to get applebutter. The applebutter is delicious, and it's almost gone😊
I just loved the "Amish Surprise Box" I received recently! I loved each and every item that was included in the box!! My most favorite item, however, was a beaded necklace that an Amish grandmother made. I have it hanging on the rearview mirror in my car right now. I plan on using each and every item. In due time I will order another surprise box for myself. It is such a nice gift to give to yourself. I am happy to receive the items, but at the same time I know I am helping the Amish community with my purchase. Thank you so much!!!
It was awesome