Simple Life Amish Store
Byler’s Butter Caramels
Byler’s Butter Caramels
Couldn't load pickup availability
Indulge in the sweet simplicity of our handmade Butter Caramel Soft Candy. Each piece is slow-cooked to perfection with real butter and fresh cream, creating a melt-in-your-mouth treat that’s soft, smooth, and irresistibly chewy.
These golden caramels capture the comforting taste of buttery sweetness with just the right hint of toasted sugar—never hard, never sticky, just pure caramel bliss. Perfect for gifting, sharing, or savoring all to yourself.
✨ Why You’ll Love It
- Handmade in small batches for quality and freshness
- Soft, buttery, and creamy—no hard crunch or stickiness
- A nostalgic treat that feels like home
Treat yourself to a little piece of golden sweetness today!
Share

They are the best caramels I have ever had will definitely order more next Christmas !
Fabulous caramels. i used these as gifts. the first recipient is a gourmet cook and she raved about them
The caramels and the service provided are superior .
I love finding “real” homemade and quality items vs all the commercial items with high costs that disappoint !
Thank you to Susan for opening up an avenue to purchase unique home goods .. a breath of fresh air !
Love them! They’re soft and chewy but not sticky. Giving some away at Christmas.m
Delicious! Highly recommend. Also makes a great gift - if you don’t eat them first lol 😁